Good stuff. It all depends, right? I get a lot of takes from big trout when trailing something small off the big one, and I’m sure that most of those fish I would not have caught.

As far as the second fly causing problems, that’s fair. But the first thing I want to see/know, after setting the hook is what fly the fish took, because that very much dictates HOW I will fight the fish.

I like this. Might use it as a podcast question. Thank you.
Dom

1. If you’re fishing a two nymph rig with flies spaced 20” apart and hook a 22” fish on the “anchor”, I’ve often had the dropper snag the tail of the fish during the fight which can lead to a break off. Yes, you can combat this by spacing your flies further apart than the length of the fish you expect to catch, but I often find having flies spaced a Namer distance apart or more to be disadvantageous for getting good dead drifts in many types of water. Also, when trout roll during a fight, the dropper can snag them as well, no matter the distance between flies.

2. A second fly will often hang up on the bottom, the bank, in a log, etc. during a fight. Multiple times I’ve had smaller fish take the second fly during a fight with the larger fish, resulting in confusion and a big fish replaced with an 8” fish.

On my home rivers in the Rockies, probably 95% of the large trout I catch are on big nymphs and small streamers (think mops, stoneflies, eggs). Since the fish are so willing to take these larger, more visible drifting flies, I find that the advantages of a second fly are outweighed by the chaos factor they introduce.

To point 3. Lmfao

Got a chuckle from that.

1. When nymphing, I find myself changing flies more frequently when only using one. Perhaps it’s purely psychological, i.e., since I’m only offering the fish one fly, perhaps I feel that I should vary my choice more. Or, perhaps it’s because I don’t worry about shortening the distance between the point and the tag fly. Whatever the reason, I’m much more likely to change point fly when it’s a singleton.

2. This is a physics question, so perhaps someone more versed in the subject can assist me, but I’ve always assumed that two independent nymphs don’t sink any faster than one nymph. Since the the point of a tag is that the flies shouldn’t influence each other (unless currents are affecting them, so one pulls at the other, but then, the descent should be slowed, not accelerated) it seems to me that, say, two 3mm. nymphs should sink at the same rate as one, not as a 6mm. nymph.

3. Dom, why do you sound like you’re from Mississippi when you say the word “style?”

I will say that I almost always have two flies on while nypmhing. I also am almost always overweighted. The two flies gives me a ton of confidence and helps me to refrain from constantly changing flies. It helps me think more about the drift than the flies. You guys brought up some good points about how two flies negatively influence your drift. I find this common in a lot of the water I fish. That’s why fish so damn heavy… Knuckle dragging.

I enjoyed the references to night fishing. You guys may have brought up some good points there.

Out of curiosity, at what weight do you find your accuracy is significantly hampered on the standard leader? I start having a hard time nailing it under low hanging branches above 60
centigrams. I can still be pretty accurate at that weight or above in open space, but when I have to use funky angles I start to make mistakes.

Thanks