I get about 150-200 days from each pair. But keep in mind that I cover about 2 miles on average on a fishing trip, and my boots never dry out between trips. I like the extra support of the G3s. That’s in the foot bed and in the uppers and the ankle. The Orvis Pros, however are significantly lighter, with almost as much support.

I get the same durability out of both. And honestly, I just wear what I have next, when one wears out.

Dom

Besides weight, how would you compare the Orvis Pros to the Simm’s G3s? I’m especially interested in your views on their relative durability. If you could only use one of these boots, which one would it be?

Hi Mike,

Personally, I don’t like the BOA laces, but plenty of anglers do.

For me, BOA is great until it isn’t. When it fails, five miles from the car, you’re in for a long walk out, whereas with a traditional boot lace, you can just tie it back together. Also, BOA systems freeze in the worst winter weather, and I fish a lot of sub zero days. Lastly, I enjoy tailoring my boot fit by using boot grommets and laces so, for example the boot is extra tight around my ankle but loose a the top. That’s not possible with BOA. I’m picky about stuff, but that doesn’t all matter to everyone out there.

Cheers.
Dom

I share many of the same opinions about these boots; I feel like they are the right balance of stability and durability, especially on the uppers. You definitely want to size up, they definitely run small. The stock laces are crap (like with most boots), I would recommend looking at Yakoda laces which are similar to the hockey laces you link to, but from a fly fishing manufacturer, have metal ends, and are cheaper.

Oh I agree totally. Nothing grips like new felt, especially with studs.

For me, though, I switched to rubber many years ago. Felt wears down very quickly, and the traction is really poor out of the water. They’re also terrible in the winter.

Cheers.
Dom

Hi Dan. I find that they run a bit smaller than Simms. Try one size up.

Thanks

Dan