Casting and Drifting | Drop Shot Nymphing on a Tight Line Rig — Pt.5

by | Jun 22, 2022 | 7 comments

** NOTE ** This is the fifth installment of the Troutbitten Short Series covering drop shot nymphing.

Find the full series HERE.

— — — — — —

How is casting any different with drop shot weight vs traditional split shot placement or weighted flies? And how is the drift on a drop shot rig different on a tight line system than on a standard fly line/leader rig?

Here in part of five of this Troutbitten Short Series about Drop Shot Nymphing, it’s time to consider the cast and the drift. Our leader is built to allow light weights to fall quickly. It’s built for accuracy and refinement in the cast, so we choose not just where the fly goes, but where and how the tippet enters. In this way, we take the tight line advantage over to a drop shot system, keeping all extra line up and out of the water, slicing the necessary tippet straight through one current seam. Because of this, we can use remarkably light weight for drop shot, even in deeper, heavier water.

In truth, the casting and the drifting doesn’t change much from a standard tight line nymphing approach. We want turnover and a fly first entry. We stick the landing, recover slack, find contact with the sighter, and then watch that sighter and feel contact with the riverbed through the fly rod. After that? Yes, a few things change about the drift.

But first, let’s address a couple specifics in the cast . . .

READ: Troutbitten | The Nine Essential Skill for Tight Line and Euro Nymphing (a ten part series)
PODCAST: Troutbitten | The Nine Essential Skill for Tight Line and Euro Nymphing (a ten part series)

Casting Changes

The danger of overweighting any nymphing rig with either beaded flies or added weight to the line is that anglers tend to lob weights around instead of casting the flies. I speak to this often, because it’s the number one thing that holds nymph fishermen back from moving forward. Lobbing is limiting. But casting opens up options that are unimaginable until you see them.

READ: Troutbitten | Fly Fishing the Mono Rig — It’s Casting, Not Lobbing

I’ll reiterate this important point. We are not overweighting the system by much here. In fact, the weight of the drop shot that I use most often is about the same as a #10 Stonefly in my box, with a 4mm tungsten bead. But drop shotting, with the weight at the end of the line, feels more direct. It simply feels heavier in the cast.

I’ve written many articles on Troutbitten regarding casting a tight line rig, and all of them apply to drop shotting. Nothing about the cast changes, so I’ll po only emphasize the following . . .

Think of all tight line rigs as contact casting systems. Any time we add weight to a fly fishing rig, we want to feel the weight load the rod. That happens on the back cast. Feel the weight tug on the rod tip and then go forward. And it happens on the forward cast too. The weight gets to the end of the line, the rod stops and the weight tucks down in. It’s a fly first entry. More accurately, in the case of drop shot, it’s a shot first entry, with the nymphs following immediately after.

With this contact casting approach, we gain full control over whatever weight we add to the system. Without it, the angler is lost, and we are hoping rather than fishing. We are guessing rather than target shooting. Use the weight of the shot, combined with the flex of the rod, to perform the cast. Keep the casting V tight. Use speed, and learn to love the feel of that contact on the end of the fly rod.

That’s good casting.

Photo by Josh Darling

Drifting — Perfecting the Bottom Ride

I grew into nymphing through the work of Joe Humphreys. And I had enough success to buy into Hump’s mantras: “If you aren’t hanging up, you won’t catch trout. You’ve got to touch that bottom to catch trout. Snagging is part of the game.” And I added my own. “Hanging up is a good thing, because wading to release it keeps you moving on to new water.”

VIDEO: Troutbitten | How to Release a Snag the Easy Way

Joe Humphreys’ point was this: The nymphs should be low — real low. And we should slow the drift to get the flies riding at the speed of the bottom current (the strike zone). Weight was necessary for this. And Humphreys often said that he added so many split shot on the tippet that it looked like a rosary.

That’s a good line. And it stuck in my mind. If I wasn’t getting down, if I wasn’t catching trout, I added weight. And I’ll be damned — it usually produced fish.

Unfortunately, it also produced a lot of snags. Humphreys wasn’t recommending drop shot. He advocated for split shot in between two flies. I still use this rig a fair amount, but I don’t use it for a bottom ride as much as I used to. Why? It hangs up about ten times as often as drop shot.

Years later, I added a sighter to my rig, I went longer on the leader and fished a Mono Rig. I also gained an understanding of the strike zone and became obsessed with getting clean strike zone rides rather than touching bottom very much. These are still my favorite nymphing dead drifts. But some days . . . it just doesn’t work as well as touching the bottom.

READ: Troutbitten | When Drifting Low Isn’t Low Enough

Photo by Josh Darling

I now use drop shot to tick, tap and touch the bottom. To slow the nymph rig, to subtly animate the nymphs with every tick, and to gain full control over the depth and speed of my rig in any water type.

That last point is the key. With a drop shot rig, by being even slightly overweighted, we are in control. But doing the right thing with that control is a big responsibility. It takes skill and refinement to feel the bottom current, to judge the speed and guide the flies naturally downstream to simulate a dead drifted nymph.

Too much bottom contact, and the drift suffers greatly. It looks fake, because real nymphs are not down there dragging, stuttering, lifting and falling dramatically. But, with too little bottom contact, the nymphs (tied above, on the line) might ride too high, up and out of the strike zone and too high to gain the trout’s interest.

In this way, guiding an overweighted system requires more skill than drifting an underweighted system. If we use less weight, we let the river decide the course of the flies. But with this drop shot system, or with a heavier tungsten point fly, for example, we have greater contact, greater control and greater responsibility.

It’s a fun challenge.

READ: Troutbitten | Over or Under — Your Best Bet on Weight

There, but Not Quite — Okay, Right There

Gaining the bottom, feeling that contact with the riverbed and then gliding over it, tap, ta-tap, tap-a-tap, maybe five to ten times throughout the drift, is success. But I’ve noticed that anglers tend to get complacent. Tickling the bottom is only half of the job. And that’s not good enough. We still need to find the right speed for a drift and keep everything in one seam.

Again, with any overweighted system, the angler is in control, and we must make these decisions.

So experiment with rates of bottom contact. Maybe less than five times each drift wil be better — maybe more than ten. Think about what looks most natural to the trout?

Remember that every time the shot touches the bottom, the nymphs jiggle above. That can be a fantastic trigger for trout. But too much of a good thing can turn them off. Aim for something natural. Aim for gliding nymphs. Practice by getting a few drifts that never touch. And then get lower. Experiment and find your way of using the riverbed and the drop shot to slow the drift and give the trout a convincing look on the flies.

And, as always, focus on keeping everything in one seam. All good nymphing starts and ends here. It’s a rare day when trout are willing to chase a nymph that is dragging across seams. They don’t eat dry flies presented that way very much, and their response on a dragging nymph is usually the same — refusal. Hold your seam. And only deviate from that baseline if the trout say no.

Final Thoughts

Remember, this is a finesse drop shot system. Yes, we are overweighted, but not a lot — not all the time.

So try to do more with less weight, and do not rely on the weight to get you down. Cast with the purpose of dropping the flies quickly and learn to let the nymphs and the weight fall efficiently.

READ: Troutbitten | Six Ways to Get Your Fly Deeper

Drop shotting puts the angler in ultimate control. Be aware of every element of the drift, and make good choices, because all of them are yours. Control is the advantage of a drop shot rig. Remember this always — your rod tip controls everything.

Fish hard, friends.

 

Next up in this Troutbitten Short Series on Drop Shot Nymphing, Part 6: Mysteries and Misunderstandings. 

** Subscribe to Troutbitten and follow along. (It’s  free.) ** 

 

** Donate ** If you enjoy this article, please consider a donation. Your support is what keeps this Troutbitten project funded. Scroll below to find the Donate Button. And thank you.

 

Enjoy the day
Domenick Swentosky
T R O U T B I T T E N
domenick@troutbitten.com

 

Share This Article . . .

Since 2014 and 1000+ articles deep
Troutbitten is a free resource for all anglers.
Your support is greatly appreciated.

– Explore These Post Tags –

Domenick Swentosky

Central Pennsylvania

Hi. I’m a father of two young boys, a husband, author, fly fishing guide and a musician. I fish for wild brown trout in the cool limestone waters of Central Pennsylvania year round. This is my home, and I love it. Friends. Family. And the river.

More from this Category

Fish and Film – Fishing Fall Streamers (VIDEO)

Fish and Film – Fishing Fall Streamers (VIDEO)

Nothing compares to actively fishing streamers and watching trout attack the fly. In early November, I found good streamer action in some favorite water. The takes were spotty enough that I had to work for them, but frequent enough that I could learn the preferences of the trout and dial in a presentation . . .

The Jerk Strip – Streamer Presentations VIDEO

The Jerk Strip – Streamer Presentations VIDEO

Moving the fly with the rod tip and not just the line hand is a fundamental skill that opens up many presentations that bring trout to a streamer.

The jerk strip is critical for any serious streamer angler. It’s a must-have skill for animating the fly — for selling the streamer to a fish. And it’s the baseline for what I think of as a jig strip, a twitch strip, a glide strip, a head flip and twitch, a lane change, and much more. At its core, the jerk strip is a hand off from left to right — it’s about moving the fly with the rod tip and then recovering with the line hand. In this way, the jerk strip sets the table for everything else . . .

Fishing Big Water – One Key Tip

Fishing Big Water – One Key Tip

Most anglers are tempted by big water. We fall for the trap. The river dares us to fish the far side, and it tricks us away from the things we do well.

. . . These are easy mistakes to make on big water. But discipline solves the problems. Actively planning and following through is an elusive quest with a fishing rod in hand. Most of us want to be creative. We want to follow our whims. The shady side of that boulder sure looks good, right? So why not make a few casts? Then fifteen minutes later, you’ve wasted time, energy and confidence with bad drifts and poor judgment . . .

Are Trout Selective About the Drift or the Position?

Are Trout Selective About the Drift or the Position?

Our small-window trout isn’t discriminating about the quality of drift, but it is picky about the location. And our larger window trout might be extra-selective about the quality of the dead drift, but it’s probably less picky about the exact location.

. . . Why did the trout eat the fly? Was it drifting naturally for a long distance, or did it enter the tight window of a waiting wild trout?

What do you think?

Be part of the Troutbitten community of ideas.
Be helpful. And be nice.

7 Comments

  1. Outstanding Dom. Roughly 2 years ago, I started drop shotting vs a shot between 2 flies. Don’t get me wrong, I’ve caught a ton of fish running shot between flies, but it’s the drop shot that I’ve found the most control. It has also allowed me to get lighter flies down. Traditionally, I don’t use many tungsten flies as my point fly. The drop shot has allowed my scud and egg patterns to ride low. Again, great write up……. JJ

    Reply
    • Thanks, John.. You are kind.
      I’m with you. I find more success by choosing drop shot as the weight rather than trying to overbuild nymphs with large beads and odd proportions. If they’re eating small stuff, drop shot is a great way to show it.

      Reply
  2. Dom: I’ve cut back to 1/48th ounce and played earlier in season with 1/32. I know it’s all relative to speed ,depth etc. And i try to underweight. My focal point used to be the slight sag in the Rio 1x as I drifted in An out of control when I placed my shot 5″ above point. That has tightened up . The focal point is now the bottom of the sighter and my barrel knot on tippet when I can see it. Should I be changing sighter angle ever so slightly through the drift to emphasize more random bottom contact. It’s been fun. Like you wrote I guess it ups your finesse game

    Reply
  3. Hi Dom great article full of lots of good hints and tips. I see you mentioned using a 4mm beaded size 10 Stonefly. Is for 4mm your bead diameter limit ? I’m Wondering what you may think about using 5mm beads and size 10 hooks eg Hanak H 400 BL or similar. Is the bead disproportionately large to simulate a “nymph” and if so does said nymph simply then become a weight, ?

    Tight lines fish hard, best AJ

    Reply
    • Hi AJ,

      No, 4 mm is not my limit. You’ll find through these Troutbitten articles that I don’t have many limits. It’s fishing. I do what works. So I use bigger beads sometimes.

      Yeah, a 5mm on a #10 takes over the fly. That’s for sure. Do trout eaat it ? If they do, excellent! Keep fishing it then.

      It’s strange to me that some anglers act like split shot is not an option. Getting all the weight from a bead is a competition, FIPS restriction that has no value for the non-comp angler. Sometimes, split shot simply outperforms weighted flies. And that’s a fact. Personally, I’d rather keep the proportions of the fly, look like something they are used to eating, and use split shot for the weight. It works wonders.

      https://troutbitten.com/2017/01/26/split-shot-vs-weighted-flies/

      Cheers.
      Dom

      Reply
  4. Hello Dom thank you very much for your comments. On your question about the number of trout eats using the 5mm beaded nymph, personally I don’t use them very often on nymphs principally because when I have I rarely get a take. I agree on a size 10 hook they don’t look “right”.

    5mm beaded nymphs are commonly used in NZ on a “ truck and trailer” rig fished under a big yarn indicator on a long leader especially in the winter fishing area. The 5mm nymph is called “ a bomb” so is more of a weight / redundant fly. When I have used this rig I rarely get takes on the heavy “bomb” nymph. Interestingly takes on the bomb are often talking points as they are rare ! Not sure if that is because in the trouts eye the fly profile is off balance / not normal or because this trailer fly is commonly tied off the bend of the hook and on a long leader take sensitivity is reduced.

    When there is a need for a fast decent into the zone, in heavy winter flow (30plus cumecs) deep pools (8 to 15 plus feet) for winter trout more interested in completing their spawning run than eating then it seems sensible to rig up a drop shot rig on a tight line system or an indicator rig. As you why not keep the nymphs as good facsimile of real food and use a weight as a weight, especially when use of shot on the leader is an allowable option. The result as you say is more trout into the net.

    The only FIPS style rules we come up against in some parts of NZ is leaders are restricted to a max length of 6 meters ( 21 feet) and one must use a fly line. Sadly these rules mean using a mono rig or long French leader is illegal but Euro nymph fly lines are allowed.

    5mm beads on a big streamer might be another story.

    Sorry if I rambled on too much.

    Stay safe fish hard and many tight lines

    Best AJ

    Reply
  5. Hey Dom, thanks for the time and energy you put into this series. I have been fishing the drop shot a lot more frequently lately, especially at night. This is good stuff. I am planning on abandoning my family this weekend to hit the river. I am going to exclusively work with this technique as I still have some deficiencies to overcome , primarily strike detection.

    Happy New Year

    Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent Articles

Recent Posts

Domenick Swentosky

Central Pennsylvania

Hi. I’m a father of two young boys, a husband, author, fly fishing guide and a musician. I fish for wild brown trout in the cool limestone waters of Central Pennsylvania year round. This is my home, and I love it. Friends. Family. And the river.

Pin It on Pinterest